Current and Upcoming Classes, Workshops, and Tutoring for Kids

An Hour on the Carpet, or, Why I Do This Work

She was six, and she was brilliant, but she frightened everyone.

I'll call her Amaya. That isn't her name — I'm not going to put a real child's worst year on the internet. So I'll say only this: it got bad enough one boy in my class was so afraid of her that his mother sat in our classroom with him, all day, for over a week.

By early October, every adult available had been called in. Administrators. Counselors. Her family. Me. We met, and we strategized, and I still sent her to the principal's office more times than I have sent any other child before or since. Two months of the full weight of adult intervention, and we had not made a dent.

Then my partner said something I didn't want to hear: that my class had gotten genuinely good at the peace table and the reflection table — better than most adults are at those things — and that maybe I should let them solve it.

I scoffed. She pushed back. 

So I sat with why I'd scoffed, and I didn't like the answer. I had a whole philosophy that said my students were my collaborators. That the people closest to a problem understand it best. And the moment a real problem arrived — the hardest one I'd ever had — I took it straight to the grown-ups and left the children out of it. I was being ageist. I was not living my own values.

So the next day I asked.

I asked her first, privately. Was she happy with how school was going? She wasn't. Would she be willing to work on it with the whole class? She would. Then she went to counseling, and I asked the class the same questions: is this a problem, and can we solve it together? It was, and they agreed that we could.

That afternoon, the last hour of the day, we moved to the carpet.

Amaya sat front and center. The rest of us made a semicircle around her. I said why we were there — that we'd all agreed to work on this together — and then I asked her to tell the class in her own words.

She said, "I want to be a good girl, but I don't think I know how."

I watched every six-year-old in that room turn their whole attention on her.

Then we tried to understand the problem before we tried to solve it.

Show of hands: who here has felt that she's been mean to them? Every hand in the room went up. She was taken aback.

Show of hands: who here has felt unsafe, or physically threatened by her? About three quarters of the room. She got upset and tried to hide her face. I told her it was okay — we were going to solve this. We just had to understand it first. That there was an important question we hadn’t asked yet. The most important. 

Show of hands: who here has had at least one good moment with her? About three quarters of the room.

I said it out loud, so nobody could miss it. There is good in here. Amaya has told us she wants to be good and doesn't know how. We agree that she doesn't know how. Let’s start by giving her credibility and believe her when she says she wants to.

Then we opened the floor. First for the times she'd been unfriendly. Then for the times she'd been unsafe.

Somewhere in there a boy told his story, and she pushed back, indignant: well, you pushed me right before I hit you... His face told the truth, that she was right. And he knew- what he'd done hadn't been kind either, neither kind nor safe.

He burst into tears.

Before I could move, another child appeared with a box of tissues. They were more ready than I was. The kids took care of him while he cried.

And then, without any help from me, the room found the thing I had been trying to teach all year. Here was a well-liked boy who had done something bad. He was sitting right in front of them, sobbing about it. And not one of them decided he was a bad kid. He was a good kid who had made a bad choice.

Which meant she might be one too.

That is the whole distinction, and it is the one that matters most. Doing something wrong is a thing you can repair. Being something wrong is a thing you can only be. We had all been treating her as the second kind — every adult in that building — and I suspect she had started to agree with us. It took a room of six-year-olds about a minute to take that apart.

So we talked about it. All of us are unfriendly sometimes. All of us need help with it. Not her. Us.

Then we did the last round: the times she'd been friendly. That one was good for everybody. It’s important to take time to remember and name the good too. A reminder of how dynamic life is. How dynamic each of us is. 

And then I asked, what do you think we should do?

I did not lead this part. They did. Well, they said, she told us she doesn't know how. But we know what feels good to us. So we can tell her.

Here is what a room of six-year-olds built:

When you're being unfriendly, we'll tell you. We'll name exactly what it was. Then you can go to the reflection table, think about it, and try again.

When you're being friendly, we'll name that too. We'll tell you what you did that felt good, and we'll invite you in.

That was the whole intervention.

We went from three or more incidents a day to none.

It held through the rest of the fall. When we came back from Christmas break, something had changed at home and things got hard for her again — and they helped her back. That's the sentence I'd keep if I could only keep one: when it broke, they already knew how to fix it. Nobody had to call a meeting.

By spring she was someone else.

An incredibly shy girl in our class got startled by her own voice, making a joyful and loud noise when no one else did. She seemed to have shocked herself, and, mortified that people had looked at her, started sobbing — the hiccuping kind that won't stop. And Amaya — this child who in August had seemed to have no access to empathy at all — went over to her.

Are you sad?

The girl hiccuped, face dripping, and nodded.

Do you want a hug?

She nodded, and Amaya hugged her, and it didn't work. The girl kept crying. I watched Amaya's face go perplexed — and then land on something.

Can I show you what I do when I have big feelings?

The girl nodded. Amaya put one hand on each of her shoulders, looked her right in the eye, and said "do what I do." She took a big slow breath in, and slowly blew it out, as though blowing out a candle. In, and out, and in again, until the girl was breathing with her.

That's the moment people expect me to end on, and it is lovely. But it isn't the point.

The point is what the rest of us learned. A team of trained, credentialed, well-meaning adults — me included — worked that problem for two months and moved nothing. A room of six-year-olds solved it in an hour, and then kept their own agreement all year. The boy whose mother had been sitting in our classroom felt safe. Every child in that room found out they were capable of changing something the grown-ups couldn't.

They didn't reduce the harm. They transformed the situation, and every life in that room along with it. Mine included.

Years later, after I'd left the classroom, I helped write a resource for educators about building alternatives to punishment. There's a section in it on the difference between doing something wrong and being something wrong. The peace table is in there. So is the reflection table, and the case for making agreements with children instead of rules for them. Teachers I will never meet are using it. Families and teams and book groups could use it too. 

Almost none of it came from me. It came from so many others. And it came from a carpet, on an October afternoon, from a room of six-year-olds who understood something I had to be taught. I have spent every year since trying to be as good at this as they were that day.

That's why I do this work. Kids can do so much more than we give them credit for. We just have to give them the tools, show them how they work, support their practice and then get out of their way.  Giving up control is usually the hardest part. But wow, is it ever rewarding.